Journal Information


METHODS FOR MEASURING DENITRIFICATION: DIVERSE APPROACHES TO A DIFFICULT PROBLEM

Peter M. Groffman1,10, Mark A. Altabet2, J. K. Böhlke3, Klaus Butterbach-Bahl4, Mark B. David5, Mary K. Firestone6, Anne E. Giblin7, Todd M. Kana8, Lars Peter Nielsen9, and Mary A. Voytek3

1Institute of Ecosystem Studies, Box AB, Millbrook, New York 12545 USA

2School for Marine Science and Technology, University of Massachusetts Dartmouth, New Bedford, Massachusetts 02744-1221 USA

3U.S. Geological Survey, 431 National Center, 12201 Sunrise Valley Drive, Reston, Virginia 20192 USA

4Institute for Meteorology and Climate Research, Atmospheric Environmental Research, Karlsruhe Research Centre, Kreuzeckbahnstraße 19, Garmisch-Partenkirchen D-82467, Germany

5University of Illinois, Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Sciences, 1102 S Goodwin, W-503 Turner Hall, MC 047, Urbana, Illinois 61801 USA

6University of California, Department of Environmental Science, Policy and Management, 151 Hilgard Hall, Berkeley, California 94720 USA

7Marine Biological Laboratory, The Ecosystems Center, 7 MBL Street, Woods Hole, Massachusetts 02543 USA

8University of Maryland, Marine-Estuarine-Environmental Sciences, Horn Point Laboratory, College Park, Maryland 20742 USA

9Department of Microbial Ecology, Institute of Biology, University of Aarhus, Ny Munkegade, Building 540, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark



Denitrification, the reduction of the nitrogen (N) oxides, nitrate (NO3) and nitrite (NO2), to the gases nitric oxide (NO), nitrous oxide (N2O), and dinitrogen (N2), is important to primary production, water quality, and the chemistry and physics of the atmosphere at ecosystem, landscape, regional, and global scales. Unfortunately, this process is very difficult to measure, and existing methods are problematic for different reasons in different places at different times. In this paper, we review the major approaches that have been taken to measure denitrification in terrestrial and aquatic environments and discuss the strengths, weaknesses, and future prospects for the different methods. Methodological approaches covered include (1) acetylene-based methods, (2) 15N tracers, (3) direct N2 quantification, (4) N2:Ar ratio quantification, (5) mass balance approaches, (6) stoichiometric approaches, (7) methods based on stable isotopes, (8) in situ gradients with atmospheric environmental tracers, and (9) molecular approaches. Our review makes it clear that the prospects for improved quantification of denitrification vary greatly in different environments and at different scales. While current methodology allows for the production of accurate estimates of denitrification at scales relevant to water and air quality and ecosystem fertility questions in some systems (e.g., aquatic sediments, well-defined aquifers), methodology for other systems, especially upland terrestrial areas, still needs development. Comparison of mass balance and stoichiometric approaches that constrain estimates of denitrification at large scales with point measurements (made using multiple methods), in multiple systems, is likely to propel more improvement in denitrification methods over the next few years.

Keywords: denitrification, greenhouse effect, nitrate, nitric oxide, nitrogen, nitrous oxide, stable isotopes, water quality

Received: December 20, 2004; Revised: June 3, 2005; Accepted: July 15, 2005; Revised: September 20, 2005

Cited by

Robinson W. Fulweiler, Scott W. Nixon. (2009) Responses of benthic–pelagic coupling to climate change in a temperate estuary. Hydrobiologia 629:1, 147-156
Online publication date: 1-Sep-2009.
CrossRef
Wim H. Putten, R. D. Bardgett, P. C. Ruiter, W. H. G. Hol, K. M. Meyer, T. M. Bezemer, M. A. Bradford, S. Christensen, M. B. Eppinga, T. Fukami, L. Hemerik, J. Molofsky, M. Schädler, C. Scherber, S. Y. Strauss, M. Vos, D. A. Wardle. (2009) Empirical and theoretical challenges in aboveground–belowground ecology. Oecologia 161:1, 1-14
Online publication date: 1-Sep-2009.
CrossRef
DENISE A. BRUESEWITZ, JENNIFER L. TANK, STEPHEN K. HAMILTON. (2009) Seasonal effects of zebra mussels on littoral nitrogen transformation rates in Gull Lake, Michigan, U.S.A.. Freshwater Biology 54:7, 1427-1443
Online publication date: 1-Aug-2009.
CrossRef
Emilie K. Stander, Joan G. Ehrenfeld. (2009) Rapid Assessment of Urban Wetlands: Do Hydrogeomorphic Classification and Reference Criteria Work?. Environmental Management 43:4, 725-742
Online publication date: 1-May-2009.
CrossRef
Daniel Weymann, Reinhard Well, Carolin Heide, Jürgen Böttcher, Heiner Flessa, Wilhelmus H. M. Duijnisveld. (2009) Recovery of groundwater N2O at the soil surface and its contribution to total N2O emissions. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems
Online publication date: 22-Apr-2009.
CrossRef
Peter M. Groffman, Eric A. Davidson, Sybil Seitzinger. (2009) New approaches to modeling denitrification. Biogeochemistry 93:1-2, 1-5
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2009.
CrossRef
Christina Tonitto, Mark B. David, Laurie E. Drinkwater. (2009) Modeling N2O flux from an Illinois agroecosystem using Monte Carlo sampling of field observations. Biogeochemistry 93:1-2, 31-48
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2009.
CrossRef
Peter M. Groffman, Klaus Butterbach-Bahl, Robinson W. Fulweiler, Arthur J. Gold, Jennifer L. Morse, Emilie K. Stander, Christina Tague, Christina Tonitto, Philippe Vidon. (2009) Challenges to incorporating spatially and temporally explicit phenomena (hotspots and hot moments) in denitrification models. Biogeochemistry 93:1-2, 49-77
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2009.
CrossRef
John Karl Böhlke, Ronald C. Antweiler, Judson W. Harvey, Andrew E. Laursen, Lesley K. Smith, Richard L. Smith, Mary A. Voytek. (2009) Multi-scale measurements and modeling of denitrification in streams with varying flow and nitrate concentration in the upper Mississippi River basin, USA. Biogeochemistry 93:1-2, 117-141
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2009.
CrossRef
Mark B. David, Stephen J. Del Grosso, Xuetao Hu, Elizabeth P. Marshall, Gregory F. McIsaac, William J. Parton, Christina Tonitto, Mohamed A. Youssef. (2009) Modeling denitrification in a tile-drained, corn and soybean agroecosystem of Illinois, USA. Biogeochemistry 93:1-2, 7-30
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2009.
CrossRef
R. Well, H. Flessa. (2009) Isotopologue signatures of N 2 O produced by denitrification in soils. Journal of Geophysical Research 114:G2,
Online publication date: 1-Feb-2009.
CrossRef
Clemens Scheer, Reiner Wassmann, Klaus Butterbach-Bahl, John P. A. Lamers, Christopher Martius. (2009) The relationship between N2O, NO, and N2 fluxes from fertilized and irrigated dryland soils of the Aral Sea Basin, Uzbekistan. Plant and Soil 314:1-2, 273-283
Online publication date: 1-Feb-2009.
CrossRef
Scott H. Ensign, Michael F. Piehler, Martin W. Doyle. (2009) Riparian zone denitrification affects nitrogen flux through a tidal freshwater river. Biogeochemistry
Online publication date: 3-Jan-2009.
CrossRef
Pamela H.  Templer, Whendee L.  Silver, Jennifer  Pett-Ridge, Kristen  M. DeAngelis, Mary K.  Firestone. (2008) PLANT AND MICROBIAL CONTROLS ON NITROGEN RETENTION AND LOSS IN A HUMID TROPICAL FOREST. Ecology 89:11, 3030-3040
Online publication date: 2-Nov-2008.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (285 KB) 
Danielle M. Gift, Peter M. Groffman, Sujay S. Kaushal, Paul M. Mayer. (2008) Denitrification Potential, Root Biomass, and Organic Matter in Degraded and Restored Urban Riparian Zones. Restoration Ecology
Online publication date: 1-Oct-2008.
CrossRef
Amy J. Burgin, Stephen K. Hamilton. (2008) NO3 −-Driven SO4 2− Production in Freshwater Ecosystems: Implications for N and S Cycling. Ecosystems 11:6, 908-922
Online publication date: 1-Oct-2008.
CrossRef
E. M. Baggs. (2008) A review of stable isotope techniques for N2O source partitioning in soils: recent progress, remaining challenges and future considerations. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry 22:11, 1664-1672
Online publication date: 15-Jul-2008.
CrossRef
Madhura V  Kulkarni, Peter M  Groffman, Joseph B  Yavitt. (2008) Solving the global nitrogen problem: it's a gas!. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 6:4, 199-206
Online publication date: 1-May-2008.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (710 KB) 
J. J. BEAULIEU, C. P. ARANGO, S. K. HAMILTON, J. L. TANK. (2008) The production and emission of nitrous oxide from headwater streams in the Midwestern United States. Global Change Biology 14:4, 878-894
Online publication date: 1-May-2008.
CrossRef
Sybil Seitzinger. (2008) Nitrogen cycle: Out of reach. Nature 452:7184, 162-163
Online publication date: 13-Apr-2008.
CrossRef
Sujay S.  Kaushal, Peter M.  Groffman, Paul M.  Mayer, Elise  Striz, Arthur J.  Gold. (2008) EFFECTS OF STREAM RESTORATION ON DENITRIFICATION IN AN URBANIZING WATERSHED. Ecological Applications 18:3, 789-804
Online publication date: 1-Apr-2008.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (3261 KB) 
Kyle S. Herrman, Virginie Bouchard, Richard H. Moore. (2008) Factors affecting denitrification in agricultural headwater streams in Northeast Ohio, USA. Hydrobiologia 598:1, 305-314
Online publication date: 1-Mar-2008.
CrossRef
C. P. Arango, J. L. Tank. (2008) Land use influences the spatiotemporal controls on nitrification and denitrification in headwater streams. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27:1, 90
Online publication date: 1-Feb-2008.
CrossRef
Denise A. Bruesewitz, Jennifer L. Tank, Melody J. Bernot. (2008) Delineating the effects of zebra mussels (Dreissena polymorpha) on N transformation rates using laboratory mesocosms. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27:2, 236
Online publication date: 1-Feb-2008.
CrossRef
P. B. McMahon, J. K. Böhlke, L. J. Kauffman, K. L. Kipp, M. K. Landon, C. A. Crandall, K. R. Burow, C. J. Brown. (2008) Source and transport controls on the movement of nitrate to public supply wells in selected principal aquifers of the United States. Water Resources Research 44:4,
Online publication date: 1-Feb-2008.
CrossRef
D. M. Kool, N. Wrage, O. Oenema, J. Dolfing, J. W. Van Groenigen. (2007) Oxygen exchange between (de)nitrification intermediates and H2O and its implications for source determination of NO3− and N2O: a review. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry 21:22, 3569-3578
Online publication date: 30-Dec-2007.
CrossRef
S.  Lefebvre, J.-C.  Clément, G.  Pinay, C.  Thenail, P.  Durand, P.  Marmonier. (2007) 15N-NITRATE SIGNATURE IN LOW-ORDER STREAMS: EFFECTS OF LAND COVER AND AGRICULTURAL PRACTICES. Ecological Applications 17:8, 2333-2346
Online publication date: 1-Dec-2007.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (330 KB) 
Cailin H.  Orr, Emily H.  Stanley, Karen A.  Wilson, Jacques C.  Finlay. (2007) EFFECTS OF RESTORATION AND REFLOODING ON SOIL DENITRIFICATION IN A LEVEED MIDWESTERN FLOODPLAIN. Ecological Applications 17:8, 2365-2376
Online publication date: 1-Dec-2007.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (598 KB) 
Oliver Spott, C. Florian Stange. (2007) A new mathematical approach for calculating the contribution of anammox, denitrification and atmosphere to an N2 mixture based on a15N tracer technique. Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry 21:14, 2398-2406
Online publication date: 30-Aug-2007.
CrossRef
Christina Tonitto, Mark B. David, Changsheng Li, Laurie E. Drinkwater. (2007) Application of the DNDC model to tile-drained Illinois agroecosystems: model comparison of conventional and diversified rotations. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 78:1, 65-81
Online publication date: 23-May-2007.
CrossRef
Eric A.  Davidson, Sybil  Seitzinger. (2006) THE ENIGMA OF PROGRESS IN DENITRIFICATION RESEARCH. Ecological Applications 16:6, 2057-2063
Online publication date: 1-Dec-2006.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (92 KB) 
S.  Seitzinger, J. A.  Harrison, J. K.  Böhlke, A. F.  Bouwman, R.  Lowrance, B.  Peterson, C.  Tobias, G. Van  Drecht. (2006) DENITRIFICATION ACROSS LANDSCAPES AND WATERSCAPES: A SYNTHESIS. Ecological Applications 16:6, 2064-2090
Online publication date: 1-Dec-2006.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (646 KB) 
Elizabeth W.  Boyer, Richard B.  Alexander, William J.  Parton, Changsheng  Li, Klaus  Butterbach-Bahl, Simon D.  Donner, R. Wayne  Skaggs, Stephen J. Del  Grosso. (2006) MODELING DENITRIFICATION IN TERRESTRIAL AND AQUATIC ECOSYSTEMS AT REGIONAL SCALES. Ecological Applications 16:6, 2123-2142
Online publication date: 1-Dec-2006.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (271 KB) 
Mark B.  David, Lareina G.  Wall, Todd V.  Royer, Jennifer L.  Tank. (2006) DENITRIFICATION AND THE NITROGEN BUDGET OF A RESERVOIR IN AN AGRICULTURAL LANDSCAPE. Ecological Applications 16:6, 2177-2190
Online publication date: 1-Dec-2006.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (337 KB) 
Lesley K.  Smith, Mary A.  Voytek, John Karl  Böhlke, Judson W.  Harvey. (2006) DENITRIFICATION IN NITRATE-RICH STREAMS: APPLICATION OF N2:Ar AND 15N-TRACER METHODS IN INTACT CORES. Ecological Applications 16:6, 2191-2207
Online publication date: 1-Dec-2006.
Abstract . Full Text . PDF (235 KB)